Saturday, May 26, 2007

meaning less

A few days ago, a very nice person said to me, "Niobe, you're a survivor"
"Oh," I said, "What makes you think that I've survived?"

13 comments:

meg said...

Sigh...that would annoy me. You are right there's no surviving, there's just limping along with what's left of us. Sounds bitter, but it's true.

laura said...

a friend's mom kept trying to encourage me after my first son's stillbirth by saying, "it only happens to the strong," and shaking her head dramatically. you can just imagine how much better those words of wisdom made me feel every goddamned time. i finally stopped returning the friend's phone calls so i could avoid social contact with the mother.

Aurelia said...

I never know how to reply to this kind of comment. Yours is good...I may steal it.

Lori said...

So I am curious as to what that person said in response to your response?

Sara said...

Oh, I know the person meant well, but that kind of comment makes me retch.

Doughnut said...

Some might say you are in recovery for things you had no control over and things you cannot change but wish like hell that you could.

niobe said...

I dunno. Afterwards, I felt that I had been, at a minimum, not very nice to someone who, annoying though she was, meant well.

Bon said...

sometimes i think it's okay to be not very nice to people when they're being stupid, no matter how well they mean. because how the hell else are they ever going to learn that platitudes aren't really so marvellous and heart-warming?

but then i usually chicken out, or at least feel bad.

i wish i didn't.

Roxanne said...

That comment doesn't upset me. Not like the ...I could never do it...comment. You really don't know what you could do until you have to do it.

I actually think that's a nice comment. You did survive something very traumatic. You didn't give up. You didn't off yourself. And you're even trying to figure out a way to have a living child--as safely as you can.

The more time that passes for me the prouder I am of myself for being much stronger than I ever thought I was. I think that being a survivor is something to be proud of...because you could just be a victim and give up.

Just my opinion.

niobe said...

Vixanne -- Maybe, in time, I'll feel more like a survivor. Right now, I don't feel that way at all.
I guess from the outside, it may look as if I haven't given up, but I think that's mostly smoke and mirrors.

Roxanne said...

I'm sorry. :( You seem very strong from your posts. I hope you grow to feel like a survivor in time.

AJW5403 said...

I know how some comments can really cute you to the bone. The one that gets me is "you are such a strong person". I hate that one the worst because I am not strong just getting by the best I can.

Yankee T said...

(niobe)